KING COUNTY LITIGATION

KING COUNTY, 3 JUDGE PANEL RULING

TRANSCRIPTS*

Transcripts of hearings listed below are to be restricted in their use. Printing a copy of the transcript without the permission from the listed transcriber is prohibited.

Day 1 - January 2nd, 2008, 176 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 2 - January 3rd, 2008, 221 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 3 - January 4th, 2008, 195 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 4 - January 7th, 2008, 196 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 5 - January 8th, 2008, 217 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 6 - January 9th, 2008, 216 pgs, posted 3/12/08
Day 7 - January 10th, 2008, 261 pgs, posted 3/12/08

Please note there are 1,482 pages of transcript. Each day may take a minute or two to load due to the large size of the document.

EXHIBITS

List of Exhibits, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #2 - Email July 26,2007 to Techs from Gullberg, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #3 - August 2007 Memo - The "Spokane" Memo, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #4 - 04040 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #5 - 05014 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #6 - 06042 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #7 - 07003 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #8 - 07004 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #9 - 07005 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #10 - 06044 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #11 - 06045 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #12 - 06046 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #13 - 06047 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #14 - 07002 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #15 - 06042 Wksht w/ Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #16 - 140035 QA Database (9-27-05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #17 - 140035 Database 9/27/05 to 10/02/06, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #18 - 05012 Gullberg Signs for Louis, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #19 - 05024 Wksht with Declarations, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #20 - Simulator Solution Protocol 10/05/07, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #21 - WAC 448-16-060 (truncating), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #22 - Simulator Solution Protocol 12/18/07, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #23 - 140002 QA (05/23/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #24 - 949265 QA (04/24/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #25 - 05008 Worksheet and "review form," posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #26 - 06048 Worksheet and "review form," posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #27 - 949275 QA (05/17/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #28 - 949261 QA (06/01/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #29 - 949252 QA (07/29/02), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #30 - 949231 QA (04/12/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #31 - 949274 QA (04/26/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #32 - 949272 QA (04/12/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #33 - 949226 QA (06/01/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #34 - 140002 QA (05/26/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #35 - 949126 QA (03/20/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #36 - 949252 QA (06/01/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #37 - 1994 Dubowski Article, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #38 - 949113 QA (01/11/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #39 - 949130 QA (01/24/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #40 - 949203 QA (01/18/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #41 - 949214 QA (01/18/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #42 - 949262 QA (07/06/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #43 - 949266 QA (06/11/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #44 - 140020 QA (01/31/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #45 - 140024 QA (02/12/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #46 - 140025 QA (02/14/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #47 - 140036 QA (07/16/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #48 - 140046 QA (07/17/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #49 - 140075 QA (12/06/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #50 - 140084 QA (01/05/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #51 - 140112 QA (12/05/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #52 - 140117 QA (12/12/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #53 - 06037 Wksht, Review sheet & "Lined Out" Chrom, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #54 - 06028 & 02019 Machines QA, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #55 - QA's for Machines using 06028, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #56 - QA's for Machines using 02019, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #57 - 140119 QA (11/01/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #58 - Calculations by Gullberg, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #59 - Excerpt: Modern Elementary Statistics (Freund) , posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #60 - Excerpt: Intro to Error Analysis (Taylor), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #61 - Excerpt: Data Analysis for Scientists & Engineers (Meyer), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #62 - Excerpt: Stat. Analysis of Exp. Data (Mandel), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #63 - Gullberg letter to editor: Jnl Anal Toxicology (1990), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #65 - Breath test tickets for matters joined in this case, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #66 - Summary of solutions used in this case, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #67 - Gullberg calculations of defendants' cases, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #68 - Excerpt: Dealing w/ Uncertainty Chem. Testing, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #69 - Audit re: control - 10/26/07 (pg 10), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #70 - Sim Sol readings 72-74/86-88, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #71 - CV of Gullberg, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #72 - List of QA's and dates (with batch 02018), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #73 - 18714 Breath Tests Affected Statewide,
Exhibit #73, Part I - List of Breath Tests Affected, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #73, Part II - 140002-949265, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #73, Part III - 949272-949113, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #73, Part IV - 949130-140075, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #73, Part V - 140046-140020, posted 1/28/080
Exhibit #74 - 18714 Breath Tests Affected Statewide
Exhibit #74, Part I - List of Breath Tests Affected, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #74, Part II - 140119-140083, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #74, Part III - 140082-140026, posted 1/28/08
Part IV - 140023-949253 , posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75 -18714 Breath Tests Affected Statewide
Exhibit #75, Part I - List of Breath Tests Affected, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75, Part II - 921042-949029, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75, Part III - 949033-949211, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75, Part IV - 949219-949228, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75, Part V - 949232-949242, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #75, Part VI - 949243-949274, posted 1/28/08
Exhibit #76 - 949224 QA (08/14/02), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #77 - 140014 QA (01/11/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #78 - 140014 Database, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #79 - 140002 QA (05/26/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #80 - 140002 Database, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #84 - 140016 QA (02/15/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #85 - 140016 Database, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #86 - Denton's CV, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #87 - 05010 Batch worksheet, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #88 - Prosecutor Chart: "Has a Ticket changed?", posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #89 - 02018 worksheet and chromatograms, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #90 - 02019 worksheet and chromatograms, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #91 - Sim sol protocols (10/23/04), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #92 - QA protocols (10/24/04), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #93 - Sim sol protocols (12/01/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #94 - Sim sol protocols (03/26/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #95 - QA protocols (08/07/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #96 - Sim sol protocols (08/07/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #97 - QA protocols (10/05/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #98 - Sim sol protocols (10/05/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #99 - QA protocols (12/18/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #100 - Sim sol protocols (12/18/07), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #101 - Breathtest program policy and procedural Manual, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #102 - GC protocols (10/23/04), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #103 - GC protocols (10/10/06), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #104 - Email btwn Rod Gullberg & Ken Denton, posted 1/28/07, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #105 - ABFT ((manual??), posted 1/28/07, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #106 - FSAB Standards/ISO Standards, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #107 - ASCLD/Lab Newsletter 06/01/07, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #108 - ISO standards ASCLD/LAB 2006, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #109 - Issue paper prepared by Logan, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #110 - SOFT Guidelines 2006, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #111 - NIST S.P. #260-125, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #112 - Transcript of Anonymous Tip, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #113 - Forensic Lab Mngmnt Practices - Guidelines, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #114 - Interoffice communication with Stephen Davis, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #115 - 05017 -Testing by Pemberton for AMG (05/23/05), posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #116 - Audit #2 -- 2007 w/o Response, posted 1/28/07
Exhibit #117 - Logan's CV, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #118 - Audit dated 09/04/07 w/ response, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #119 - Audit #3 (10/24/07 - 10/26/07), posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #120 - Summary of Audits,
Exhibit #121 - Chart made with Logan on flip pad, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #122 - Lisa Noble Declaration re: Siim Sol #06028, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #123 - Amanda Black Declaration re: Sim Sol #07008, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #124 - Sarah Swenson Declaration re: Sim Sol #06020, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #125 - Chris Johnston Declaration re: Sim Sol #07041, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #126 - Brian Capron Declaration re: Sim Sol #05009, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #127 - Brianna Peterson Declaration re: Sim Sol #07031, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #128 - Naziha Nuwayhid Declaration re: 06016, 06019, 06031, 06049, 07018, posted 1/30/08
Exhibit #129 - Chart of Solutions mentioned with problems, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #130 - 11/04/05 Policy Manual, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #131 - Email from Bexar County Med Examiner to Logan, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #132 - Listing of errors made by Callahan (non-software related - 151 total), posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #133 - Table of Rejected Data - Pemberton and Logan, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #134 - OIML 126 - Most recent committee draft, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #135 - Emory's cv, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #136 - ISO Guide 35: 2006, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #137 - ISO/IEC #17025 (1999), posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #138 - ISO Guide 34:2000 (of note: 5.13.2a), posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #139 - ISO Guide 35:2006, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #140 - ASTM E 178-02, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #141 - NIST Special Publication 260-100
Exhibit #141, Part I ,NIST Special Pub 260-100, posted 2/4/08, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #141, Part II ,NIST Special Pub 260-100, posted 2/4/08, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #142 - Crime Lab Report Publication, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #143 - ASCLD/LAB Accreditation, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #144 - ILAC G19: 2002, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #145 - Declaration of Barry Logan - "TABLE ONE" ONLY, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #146 - Document identifying sim sols w/ calculations by T.Vosk, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #147 - Consensus Values & Weight Factors (Paule & Mandel -1982), posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #148 - Estimation of Common Mean and Weigh Means Stats, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #149 - Tables of Ranges - g/100ml Sol Values, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #150 - Observations of Sol Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #151 - Excluded Data Analysis, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #152 - Polizzar's CV, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #153 - Observations of Sol Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #154 - Comparison of Weighted & Unweighted Means, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #155 - Comparison of Means of Solutions used in this Case, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #156 - CV of al SOl Available on the Web - Bar Charts, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #157 - Excluded Data Analysis Chart, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #158 - Excluded Data Analysis Char, posted 2/4/08 t
Exhibit #159 - Means w/ & w/o Replacement of Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #160 - Excluded Data Analysis Chart - Identical to Exhibit #158, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #161 - Chart - Weighted and Unweighted, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #162 - Batch 6028 - Original & New Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #163 - Means w/ & w/o Replacement of Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #164 - Means w/ & w/o Replacement of Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #165 - Means with and without Replacement of Measurements, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #166 - Mean Results & Error Bars for Sim Batch 07007 on 5 Diff DataMasters, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #167 - Det. Penry's Investigation, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #168 - Statement made by M Pemberton to Det. Moate, posted 2/4/08
Exhibit #169 -Batch 7018 with Declarations and Chromatograms, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit # 169, Part I, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit # 169, Part II, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit # 169, Part III, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit #170 - Batch 3019 with Declaration and Chromatograms, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit #170, Part I, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit #170, Part II, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit #170, Part III, posted 2/7/08
Exhibit #171 - Solution Use 6003, 5008, 6048, 2018, 2019, 6028, posted 2/4/08

KING COUNTY RULINGS
South Division - Judge Seitz Ruling, posted 1/8/2008